Whose heart is it really?

[obisgirl]

Anastasia Griffith is listed in the credits of episode 18 as Kathryn/Abigail. Perhaps Kathryn's not dead after all. The heart must belong to someone else.

That is somewhat of a relief. But the writers did say the whole Kathryn storyline would be wrapped up this season.

I listened to Once and fan podcast this morning and I'm going to list who I hope the heart DOESN'T belong to:

Henry, Jr. -- that would be just really creepy of Regina if she somehow had little Henry's heart
David -- I can't think of how this would work. I think it would make more sense if David was missing his brain than his heart
Snow -- because the Evil Queen never got her heart.
Regina

I heard Colleen say it on the fan podcast and I think the heart belongs to Henry, Sr. It would make a lot of sense. But then what about MM's fingerprints on the box? I think those are fake, planted there by the curse.

[hjbau]

I think that the queen burned her father's heart though so i am not sure if it can be his. I don't want the heart to belong to anyone alive.

[slurpeez108]

Earlier, I wrote, "Anastasia Griffith is listed in the credits of episode 18 as Kathryn/Abigail. Perhaps Kathryn's not dead after all. The heart must belong to someone else." I'd like to amend that theory. Either it's not Kathryn's heart, or it is her magical heart that Regina removed in the same manner we saw Regina remove Graham's heart in episode 7. Kathryn could still be alive but in the hospital basement or some other holding cell, and Regina planted Kathryn's magical heart in a box with Mary Margaret's fingerprints.

[hjbau]

I still don't think it is Kathryn's heart.