• docxen

    @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast she was not 18 when henry came back if she was she woulda had henry at 8

    • docxen

      @docxen @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast by she i mean emma

  • docxen

    @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast On Emma’s 18th birthday, Henry shows up and they travel back to Storybrooke where Emma decides to stay.

    • docxen

      @docxen @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast If this is right emma was 8 when she had henry

    • nevrothwen

      @docxen @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast I thought it was her 28th birthday. Makes more sense.

      • docxen

        @nevrothwen @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast it is dont spoil my moment thought i got to correct daniel. I’m writing this down in my diary

        • docxen

          @docxen @nevrothwen thought=though

  • docxen

    @theRamenNoodle @OncePodcast that was quick

  • http://obisgirl.dreamwidth.org/ obisgirl

    Cinderella’s fairy godmother is destroyed but Rumpelstiltskin and he takes her want, but he still helps her get to the ball at a terrible price, Rumpelstiltskin is imprisoned (S01E04 “The Price of Gold“)

    noticed some typos, want should be “wand.”

    Gipetto is spelled Geppetto.

    • Daniel J. Lewis

      @obisgirl Thanks for pointing those out!

    • Daniel J. Lewis

      @obisgirl Thanks for pointing those out!

      • http://obisgirl.dreamwidth.org/ obisgirl

        @Daniel J. Lewis no problem.

      • http://obisgirl.dreamwidth.org/ obisgirl

        @Daniel J. Lewis no problem.

  • lostdogs20

    RT @ONCEpodcast We just updated the Fairytale Land portion of our #OnceUponaTime timeline! http://t.co/vUS7dAKN #OUaT

  • lostdogs20

    RT @ONCEpodcast We just updated the Fairytale Land portion of our #OnceUponaTime timeline! http://t.co/vUS7dAKN #OUaT

  • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

    This is great. Thanks for putting the effort into it!

  • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

    This is great. Thanks for putting the effort into it!

  • Daniel J. Lewis

    That’s exactly my point I keep making in the podcast. It just doesn’t quite make sense, unless Snow was pregnant with Emma before her wedding.

    • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

      Not sure what I’m missing there… why is the one bothered by the other?

      • Daniel J. Lewis

        I don’t quite understand what you’re asking.

      • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

        Perhaps it’s just when Cinderella got pregnant that’s out of place. Could the two couples have been married about the same time, but Snow White got prenant right away and Cinderalla not for a few months?
        The bigger question is, why is Cinderalla still pregnant when Emma arrives in Storeybrooke? How many years did she carry that child?

      • Daniel J. Lewis

        @Calixar Right. Cinderella is seriously pregnant when Rumpelstiltskin is put into prison.

        But Rumpelstiltskin was put into prison before the curse was declared—thus before Snow and James’s wedding.

        Snow gave birth to Emma on the day the curse was being enacted. So unless there was some fornication going on, the curse was enacted at least eight months after the wedding. So where was Cinderella this whole time?

        Maybe Rumpelstiltskin put some kind of curse on her that she won’t give birth until he’s free.

        And, yes, all of this would mean that Cinderella must’ve been pregnant for at least ten years (Henry’s age), but 28 years is a popular idea.

      • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

        I keep wondering about Henry’s comment about time being frozen until Emma got there (the clock stuck at 8:15)… were they previously in some sort of haze that kept them from noticing that things were not right and events were not progressing normally?

      • Daniel J. Lewis

        @Calixar Yes, that’s very likely. They spent day by day under Regina’s rule, but they never noticed the passing of time.

        This makes me wonder about Henry’s view of everything.

      • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

        @Daniel J. Lewis The idea that “bad things” happen if they try to leave town, I think, is significant. Storybrooke, like The Island, is in some sort of reality bubble. I don’t know think it’s a Minkowski Space, but it and its inhabitants are decidedly not part of our world.

        I wonder if the idea that only Regina knows the truth is itself a lie. Rumplestiltskin seems to have, at least, an idea that things are not what they seem.

      • http://jeremylaughlin.com/ Jeremy Laughlin

        @Daniel J. Lewis How do we know that Rumpelstiltskin was imprisoned before Snow and James’s wedding? At the moment I can’t think of any reason Cinderella’s wedding couldn’t have been after Snow’s.

        • Celesstar

          Rumplestiltskin had to be imprisoned AFTER Snow and James’s wedding because Snow and James attend Cinderella’s wedding as a couple. In FTL to be invited to a wedding like that as a couple means you’re officially married.

      • Daniel J. Lewis

        @Jeremy Laughlin

        1. Cinderella’s marrying Prince Thomas was her happy ending, Evil Queen said that Snow White’s wedding would be the last happy day.

        2. At Cinderella’s wedding, no one was sad, afraid, or showed any knowledge of the curse.

        3. Rumpelstiltskin was in prison when Snow White was pregnant and they sought his foretelling.

        4. Evil Queen came to Rumpelstiltskin after her curse had initially failed and he told he that James and Snow White had already been there. #3 and #4 would have had to happen quite soon after the proclamation of the curse.

        I need to rewatch the pilot episode to check some things.

      • http://jeremylaughlin.com/ Jeremy Laughlin

        @Daniel J. Lewis As far as #1 and #2 go, I’d say that EQ was all talk at Snow and James’s wedding. As we saw later, she didn’t actually have a plan when she said all that stuff. It was just a threat. Unless everyone was as worried as Snow, there’s no reason to believe that there couldn’t have possibly been any happiness between the wedding and the curse.

        #3 doesn’t present a problem with the idea that the Snow/James wedding was first.

        I don’t think #3 and #4 had to happen all that quickly after the wedding threat; EQ needed time to get the curse from Maleficent and gather “those with the darkest hearts” for her first attempt. I’m actually not sure why the whole thing took her so long, but since it did I think there’s room for Cinderella’s wedding and Rumpel’s imprisonment between the Snow/James wedding and EQ’s visit to Rumpel. For that matter, as I recall Snow was already showing quite a bit when they went to see Rumpel, and for now I think we can assume that she conceived after the wedding. She could have already been pregnant, but not very far along, at Cinderella’s wedding.

  • http://www.mikaljohnson.com/ Calixar

    So, the stranger is a writer, eh? He can, apparently, come and go as he pleases, despite that not being possible according to Henry… could he be… The Author?

    • Daniel J. Lewis

      @Calixar Could be!

  • riddleraven

    “young Geppetto…—probably 50–60 years pass—Snow White is born to King Leopold and his wife”I’m not sure about this. Geppetto was already about 10 when Jiminy came along. So by your timeline he would be 70 when Snow White was born, making him NINETY at the curse plotting session and in Storybrooke. I guess that’s possible since they probably live longer in fairy-tale land, even though he doesn’t look that old. But I think it’s more likely that he’s 10 and he meets Jiminy and then 30 years pass, snow is born, and 20 years pass to the curse. Making him 60 when Snow is 20.

    • DanielJLewis

      @riddleraven Thanks for pointing that out. That was something I overlooked when I placed Snow White’s birth.

  • jayful_says

    @natashab0518 You’re welcome. We’ll need to discuss this soon ;-) Their #OUAT timeline shows that there are still a lot of gaps.

  • NONNIE

    http://www.onceuponatimefans.co.uk/eftimelinep2.htm

    Here is a time line on another site… some differences noted… both sites are fun to read and helpful to understand OUAT .

  • Stephanie

    Couldn’t some of these things have happened simultaneously? Like some of the events of Skin Deep and Rumplestiltskin’s deals?

    • DanielJLewis

      They could have, and I try to account for that with some of the points.

  • Pingback: [Recap&Review] Once Upon A Time` Dreamy | The Weekly Enthusiast

  • http://twitter.com/icecream4younme Ice Cream

    ooh thanks for the timeline! the fairytale land is great but it would help if you could post the characters from storybrooke and their fairytale land character. obviously we all know the easier ones like regina/evil queen, mr gold/rumple, ruby/red. but the other characters are hard to keep track of.

    also it would be more beneficial to do the storybrooke timeline with just the moments in storybrooke that directly cross over to the fairytale land. like the time with the mines and they show the glass case of sleeping beauty/snow white?  or like with the hidden hearts.

    anyways thanks for all the work; love listening to you guys!

  • sjm

    Where you have -gap- seems to fit with “What happened to Frederick, ” at least the rescue part we saw.

    Also we know because of Kitsis and Horowitz that “Red-Handed” took place right after SW ran from the queen and before she met PC

    I like where Skin Deep is for now, although for some reason I thought it was closer to the end of the FT timeline, but I can’t remember why now. But after Dreamy, where you have it makes more sense.

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      We’re getting help to keep this updated. Thanks for the input!

  • Pingback: [Recap&Review] Once Upon A Time ` Red-Handed | The Weekly Enthusiast

  • Slurpeez108

    From episode 15, the Widow Lucas’s brothers were veterans of the 2nd Ogre’s War. Was that the same Ogre War during which Rumpel was turned into the Dark One? Or was it the Ogre War we heard mention of in episode 12, when Belle’s father pleaded with Rumple (who had been established as the Dark One) to spare their village from the ogres?

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      The Ogre’s War in “Skin Deep” could not have been the same one that Rumplestiltskin ran from. Rumplestiltskin became the dark one long before Geppetto was a boy. During the airing of “Skin Deep,” the writer replied to a tweet answering that Rumplestiltskin was in the first Ogre’s War.

  • Derrick Palmer

    First, THANK YOU for putting this timeline together (Fairytale Land especially). It’s needed!
    Secondly, I am new to this site and I think it’s amazing! You all elaborate on things I have thought about and mention things I never caught.
    Lastly, the first item in the Storybrook timeline says Emma is found by a 7-year-old boy. My initial assumption was ‘Pinocchio’ and August is the wooden boy, thus allowing him to enter the town (I’m assume that given that there are ‘no visitors,’ it means that only Fairytale land-born or family of those born there can enter)! SIDE NOTE: Emma was born in Fairytale Land (needs new name lol) which makes her a fairytale character even if not associated with a pre-existing character we know. If you want to go deeper, you can claim that , because Henry is born to a fairytale character, he then can be considered one himself. Ok, back on track about Pinocchio…Then I thought, “No, because he would have had to been able to leave Storybrook or evade the cures to do so.” Henry can do it because he was not born in Fairytale Land. The leaving part seems to be more associated with birthplace and less due to the effect of curse. THEN, I thought, “Pinocchio was originally wood and if he were, some crazy how, made from the same tree that was used for Baby Emma, then he could POSSIBLY have a way to leave.” I know the tree didn’t leave the fairytale land but…well, you can kinda see where that whole line of thought came from. Also, even though the boy from the first episode was never called Pinocchio by name, we can assume that it is him. Which kinda either throws my theory out the window or just adds another crazy piece to the puzzle. LOL. 

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Thanks, Derrick. And good thoughts!

  • sjm

    Thank you for all that work updating the FTL timeline, it is awesome! I loved reading through it. Seemed pretty accurate to me.

    I am wondering if there are some turning points that might be added to the SB timeline like Emma reuniting the orphans (Hansel and Gretel in FTL) with their father, or Thomas proposing to Ashley on Valentine’s Day, things that might fit into Emma having an affect on things. Also, I know the SB side is pretty much in chronological order, but there are still some highlights that might be worth remembering, especially if the show goes on for several seasons –  I am thinking particularly of Kathryn’s disappearance, Mr. Gold confronting Moe French, and the Miner’s Day celebration, MM arrested. Perhaps there are others you might think of as well. 

    Anyway, just a suggestion on the SB side of things, but again great job on the FT side. Thank you so much!

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Thanks, SJM. For now, I’ve removed the Storybrooke timeline since we weren’t updating it and the page is already really long.

  • http://obisgirl.tumblr.com obisgirl

    God, the timeline is getting to so long. Ever think about a different timeline format? 

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      I think about it all the time. I’ve been looking at alternative methods and am testing a couple. Do you have suggestions?

      • sean

        http://timeline.verite.co/

        This timeline is amazing, and lets you embed pictures and video.. and the whole thing can be fed by a google spreadsheet.

        • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

          I was about to say, “Thanks, but it doesn’t support BC yet,” but then I checked his changelog and he added it! I’ll probably be switching to this, since it’s free and more easily updated.

      • http://www.yourtechnetwork.com/ Dennis Freitas

        Yes i used a time line a few years ago on a project for my day job. Cant remember what the software was call…..lots of help, huh…lol I will find it i am sure i have the DMG somewhere.

  • Pingback: [Recap&Review] Once Upon a Time` The Stable Boy | The Weekly Enthusiast

  • Derrick Palmer

    REGINA’S LAST NAME IS MILLS! Hahaha! I get it now!

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Ha ha. Yup! We had previously suspected the relationship. Now we know!

      • Lostmommyof4

        Can you help me out with this one???

        • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

          Help you with what?

  • Bob Dole

    I don’t know if the events of Hat Trick should happen so soon on the timeline… Regina’s father, after giving the box to the Genie, completely vanishes from the screen until Regina’s trying to work the Curse. So wouldn’t it make more sense if she goes to save him right before he starts showing up again? That, and that episode has the first appearance of her Hag disguise…which tells me she’s preparing to give the apple to Snow White and stuff.

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      The Evil Queen and her castle were in black, which places “Hat Trick” after the Huntsman in “The Heart is a Lonely Hunter.”

      Regina’s father was also around just before King Leopold’s death (“Fruit of the Poisonous Tree”), Snow’s escape, and the Huntsman.

      So the events of “Hat Trick” can only fit between the Huntsman and Regina’s killing of her father.

  • Lostmommyof4

    As a new idea for the timeline, perhaps something like LOSTpedia’s timelines but as we don’t have year refrences, maybe significant events like “First Ogre War” could be large and in bold as refrence points. Here’s the LP one http://lostpedia.wikia.com/wiki/Timeline:Pre-crash

    I used those timelines endlessly as I intent to use yours if you keep it up!

    An event you might want want to add is James/ James Replacement birth implied from “The Shepherd”.

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Yes, I’ve looked at something like that. But we don’t have many definite events. Also, every timeline app I’ve looked at requires a real date.

  • Purrlisse

    Hmmm… there are some issues which are not clear… to be honest we cannot say when the story of the Mad Hatter and the queen of hearts took place. or the hansel and gretel one. I think we must understand more about what happened with the queen of hearts and the apple, and also her relationship with maleficent and rumple to know where they, and other episodes like belle, fit in.

    And I don’t agree with the cinderella timeline. The timeline is stretched in one episode, though we don’t see it, so we must assume that while cinderella is having her story, so are the other characters going about their life. So i’m assuming:

    The first prince james died.

    Rumple makes deal with King George, who in return tells him about the location of the fairygodmother.

    Rumple makes 2 deals at that time. 1. With the new prince james, 2. goes to kill the fairygodmother and deals with cinderella.

    The prince james story and his meeting with abigail and snow carry on, until he wakes snow white with a kiss.

    Cinderella gets married and invites them – possibly having met them somewhere before where we don’t know and don’t know if we’ll get to know… they look carefree so i don’t think regina’s curse has been announced yet.

    It could be that now snow and charming get married…

    Cinderella is pregnant and they capture rumple.

    Snow white is pregnant and wants to talk to rumple.

    the rest is pretty obvious.

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      See my reply to Bob Dole about the timing of “Hat Trick.”

      We don’t know how much time passed between Cinderella’s visit to the ball and her wedding. But we know her wedding came after the pronouncement of the curse (at Snow’s wedding), and probably six months before the curse was enacted.

      Hansel and Gretal fits into the timeline when Regina was looking through her mirror at Snow and the dwarfs, “Now she’s cavorting with dwarfs?” This is a view into the simultaneous events of “7:15 a.m.” because this was when Snow had just lied to James about her love and left him.

      • sjm

        at least six months since she was very pregnant when the curse was enacted and SW was very pregnant with Emma. Their weddings must have been either very close together, or some interesting timing on having their children around the same time :) 

        • ArwenRenee

          i think Snow/ Charming and Ella(Cinderella)/Thomas Weddings happen close together which is first is up in the air if you ask me. I also think they became pregnant+- close to the same time and just happens that Ella hadn’t given birth before the curse hit where she lived in FTL

          • Megan

            I think that Snow and Charmings storyline is a lot longer than you’re making it out to be. I think Regina came and made the announcement about the curse at their wedding but it was at least a couple years later before they had Emma. They just thought of the curse as an empty threat from a mad woman. Because Snow and Charming went to go see Rumple in prison and it seemed like he had been there a while. Which places Cinderella’s marraige somewhere after they got married but that means that they would to have been married for a while before the curse took affect. Snow didn’t go see Rumple until she was just barely pregnant with Emma and then the curse happened like a minute after she was born. I think Cinderella’s storyline is shorter than your thinking. Her’s happened only over the course of like 1 or 2 years. She went to the ball, then met her prince, got married in couple months and then a few weeks later was pregnant. And that’s when they captured Rumple. And that all happened after Snow and Charmings wedding.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/E2S6VBQ53EEXV77TFRLRPPYJZM April

    After your gap in time- in the second point you have Rumple being imprisoned right after making the deal. That didn’t happen until later.  I also think that Cinderella and Thomas were married before Snow and Charming because Snow wasn’t really happy after the Queen said she was going to enact the curse that would take away their happily ever afters. She seemed really happy at their wedding. The Queen also fought Maleficent for the curse on Snow and Charming’s wedding night which was stated in “The thing you love most”.  The other things I wanted to know about, you have already answered for me by letting me know that you will need more information before you can place it in the timeline. I think this timeline is really great. It might just be easier also to just put the season and episode numbers and have a episode outline on the bottom. It might also be easier to have things that happened back to back just be under one bulletin. such as *Emma is born and escapes the curse through the magic wardrobe while the Evil Queen’s forces conquer Prince Charming’s castle as the curse takes effect.– But that is just a thought as well as Underlining the Characters names so people can quickly scan it to find what they are looking for. 

  • sjm

    After the last gap in the timeline where Rumpel kills the fairygodmother, I thought he wasn’t imprisoned until signing with the quill… and if he was imprisoned how did he get out to meet Cinderella?

  • Pingback: [Recap&Review] Once Upon a Time ` The Return | The Weekly Enthusiast

  • Pingback: [Recap&Review] Once Upon a Time` The Stranger | The Weekly Enthusiast

  • angbunso

    is there going to be an update on this?  or is there a new link?

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      I just added the new timeline here. It’s still missing a lot of stuff because we need help populating it.

      • Annafab

        Why such a long time period between Rumple becoming Rumple and the curse? I have no reason to say you’re wrong but I’m just wondering about what evidence suggests it was THAT long ago.

        • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

          In “That Still Small Voice,” a young Jiminy brings things to a fully dark Rumplestiltskin in his castle. Geppetto is around 8 years old at this point.

          But when the curse struck, Geppetto looks to be in his 60s.

          Additionally, Jane Espenson has confirmed that Rumplestiltskin has been the Dark One “for centuries. He was in the first Ogres War.”

          • Annafab

            I get the 60ish year gap. It’s the centuries gap that baffles me. How many Ogre wars have there been?

            Side note: If it’s been centuries and Rumple is still hoping to find Baelfire, that would have to mean time passes differently in the real world vs the Enchanted Forest, because otherwise Baelfire would be long dead. 

          • Annafab

            Also, how do we know Snow was 13 when she met Regina? She looked younger than that to me.

  • Clockwatcher

    LOVE the new timeline! :D

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Thanks! We still need lots of help migrating the information.

  • whiteowl82

    I disagree with where you put Hat Trick and here’s why: Grace’s age. When we see her in Storybrooke, she looks about the same age as she was when we last saw her in FTL, which means that not that much time has passed between Jefferson being trapped in Wonderland and Regina casting the curse. Regina’s father could have been taken to Wonderland at any point in time, even after the events in Fruit of the Poisonous tree, which is the last time we see him before Hat Trick. In my opinion, Hat Trick takes place right before either The Price of Gold or The Thing you love Most.

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Thanks for pointing that out! I’m working on this as we speak, and I’m finding myself putting in some wrong dates as I re-evaluate things. I’ll correct this.

  • semil

    nova and dreamy meet when dreamy is 1. not 2. they even say it in a line…..

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Yes, I was moving things around as I added pieces, and hadn’t finished moving those parts.

  • http://obisgirl.tumblr.com obisgirl

    I like Jiminy’s timeline blurb:

    Jiminy gets potion from Rumpelstiltskin
    Gets a potion from
    Rumpelstiltskin to escape from his parents, but the consequences convict
    him to become a cricket so he can be a guide to young Geppetto.

    Just the mention of ‘convict’ – it’s like he’s sentenced to be a talking magical cricket for life. which he was, but it’s still funny.

    only one minor correction: I’m pretty sure the Genie killed King Leopold before the Genie made his last wish to look upon the Evil Queen’s face forever.

    • http://About.me/DanielJLewis Daniel J. Lewis

      Yes, I’m still moving things around and thus some things are incorrectly placed.

  • Slurpeez108

    I love the new timeline format! Way to go OncePodcasters!

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      Thanks! I need to get back to updating it, especially during our rewatch.

  • Dearie

    this timeline is pretty awesome. one question-how do we know the timing for belle? it has to be after jiminy (you see geppettos puppet-parents in rumplestiltskins castle in ‘skin deep) and we know it’s in return for help in the ogre wars, but how can we be sure its ‘the ogre wars flare up again’ instead of the ;second ogre war’ mentioned by ruby’s grandmother?

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      I need to finish this timeline. Essentially, we know Skin Deep’s timeline based on other events. In “Dreamy,” the dwarfs are in a tavern where Belle points out to Dreamy that he’s in love. She’s wearing the same thing she was when she left Rumplestiltskin’s castle the last time, and she didn’t have a basket like she did the first time when Queen Regina met her. (By the way, that’s another clue, the Regina is the dark queen, which also confirms this is after King Leopold’s death and Snow White’s running away).

      Also remember that in 7:15 a.m., Snow meets Grumpy in the prison, and he refers to events that took place in “Dreamy” as if they’re quite recent.

      Jane Espenson also confirmed that there have been several Ogres Wars.

  • Jessica

    I think “Baelfire, turns 14″ would come after Rumpelstiltskin helps the beggar and takes the Dark One’s powers. But thanks so much for this!

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      That was a glitch in my transfer. Thanks!

  • http://twitter.com/apollopriestess Priestess of Apollo

    I like it as well, but I don’t find the timelines confusing. Snow looks completely different in the FTL present timeline, and Emma is with her! Plus Snow had an amazing costume on this week, in the past Enchanted Forest. I love this show! But for the format I would maybe do three lines coming out from one spot: maybe make it Rumple? Maybe that would help as the 3 timelines would be separated with the events clearly indicated. Just a thought?

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      It’s working right now for everything to be linear. This system I’m using is easy to maintain, mobile-friendly, and meets my other technical requirements.

  • Nonnie

    when was the last time this time line has been up dated????

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      I’ve been slowly transitioning the old bullet-point timeline into the new, more accurate timeline, which I just updated for “The Crocodile.”

  • Pingback: [Recap&Review] Once Upon A Time ` The Doctor | Weekly Enthusiast

  • http://www.facebook.com/jaiden.lauren Jaiden Laurén Cox

    Great job with the timeline!

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      Thanks! It’s still a big work in progress, especially moving from a simple list to a timeline with dates. But I think it really helps the fans place information.

  • http://twitter.com/HMVerhagen Heather Verhagen

    Hmm…perhaps we could look into the final episode and try to decide when Rumple gave Charming the magic ring. Did the ring allow Charming to find Snow White’s coffin in the woods? (Did Rumple give him the ring because he was able to put the potion inside the dragon?) I do remember that Red and the Dwarves found Snow White once she took the apple from Regina, and that Snow was then put in the coffin by the Dwarves.

  • http://twitter.com/HMVerhagen Heather Verhagen

    All I’ve figure out about Hat Trick is that it happend after Glass became the mirror, since Regina is speaking to him when Jefferson and tries to buy Grace a toy. Hope this helps.

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      And Regina’s castle is black, which didn’t change until right after King Leopold’s death in “The Hear Is a Lonely Hunter.”

  • http://twitter.com/HMVerhagen Heather Verhagen

    Should Rumple’s birth shouldn’t be first on the timeline? The Blue Fairy is said to be the Origin of Magic, so did she exist first and create the entire world? Maybe…

  • Pingback: [Recap & Review] Once Upon A Time` Tallahassee | Weekly Enthusiast

  • katie

    im confused. it has bae getting the bean before rumple becomes the dark one?

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      Oops! That was a glitch that I’ve now corrected.

  • DannyDubner

    In the Cora kills Daniel part, it’s written David instead of Daniel (in one of the final parts)

    Awesome timeline, by the way (:

  • Justme

    The timeline doesn’t make sense anymore after this week’s episode. Rumplestilskin had to kiss a man’s boot in front of his son before he became the dark one. But he met a young Cora when he already was turned into the Dark One. That means that Rumplestilkin’s son has to be years older than Regina (and way older than Snow) which he is not.

    • Megan

      Yes he is. He left in the portal with the magic bean as a child. Rumple being the dark one doesn’t age. Back in the real world in NY, Neil/Bae said that our world wasn’t his first stop, if it had been he would be a couple hundred years old, he also says he knows Hook, and knows how to sail Hook’s ship which means he was in Neverland where people don’t age.

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      Rumple is 300 years old. The boot scene happened a long time before Cora.

  • Megan

    Don’t know how old this is, but now there’s some new information. Young Cora’s story. Cora get’s tripped by Princess Ava and humiliated infront of everyone. Cora sneaks into a royal ball for the prince to find a wife, she gets caught by the king and lies, saying she can spin straw into gold. The king locks her up in a tower with a bunch of straw and a spinning wheel. Rumplestilstkin comes to make her a deal and she learns magic. Cora marries the Prince. Cora rips out her own heart instead of the Kings so she can be powerful because she sees love as weak. Baby Regina is born.

    Then you put present time storybrooke at the the end with Snow killing Cora saving Rumple.

    • Megan

      Also Snow and Ava’s storyline which hopefully we find out more about. Ava became Queen at some point which means she married the Prince that was 1st in line for the throne. Where Cora married the 7th in line. Queen Ava gets sick and Snow seeks out the blue fairy for help. The blue fairy gives her black magic that she must keep a secret. It is now Snow’s birthday and she chooses not to use the black magic on her mom and her mom dies. Cora is the one who actually killed her and pretended to be the blue fairy and is trying to corrupt Snow. She then makes sure Regina is out riding while Snow and her father were travelling and then makes Snow’s horse go running. Setting Regina up to be queen.

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      Yes, I seriously need to update this. I’ve had volunteers step up, but none have added anything.

  • Keb

    I’ll be adding to the timeline as I can this season, though it will probably take a few days after each episode to update.

  • Meredith Pechta

    Watch “Quite a Common Fairy” carefully. I believe the flashback takes place between “We Are Both,” and “The Doctor.” That’s where you will probably place it in the timeline when you update it again.

    • Keb

      Hm, I was thinking it was post The Doctor. What evidence do you think places it before that?

  • merryweather

    I want to revise my earlier statement. I believe that “Quite a Common Fairy” takes place after “The Doctor.” Regina would never have agreed to a set-up with another man if she hadn’t given up on bringing back Daniel from the dead first. It’s still early on, since Regina is still hesitant about learning dark magic. Maybe a month or two after Dr. Frankenstien’s departure.

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      I agree with merryweather.

      • Keb

        Good, cuz that was my opinion on rewatching! I’ve put it the year after just because there’s a lot of time to fill while Snow’s growing up, but I suspect it wasn’t terribly long after then either. Will adjust as more data comes in.

  • merryweather

    Obviously you need to add the event from “Nasty Habits.” It’s obviously between “Desparate Souls” and “The Return.” I’d say two weeks before “The Return.”

  • merryweather

    There was a question in last night’s episode, as to whether Snow had already met Charming by that point. I read on twitter today that she had. It takes place between “Snow Falls” and “True North.” Obviously, this also takes place at the same time that Regina told Rumple that Belle was dead. I think she went to him to be tranformed into Ursula. Since she needed help being a peasant not long ago, it would make sense. But since Rumple refused to help her, I assume that regina then went to Maleficent for help. So when you update the timeline, please get this right.

    • Keb

      Thanks for keeping an eye on these things! I’m still catching up a bit on the timeline after moving last week, but updates are forthcoming, and I absolutely agree with your thoughts here. It does mean I’ve got some adjusting to do on some of my estimates!

  • brucegil

    Just found your timeline. You are at episode 303. If and when you update the past from flashbacks or backstories, how can we find these new updates in your timeline? Is there some way you can make them stand out visually so they can be spotted while scrolling through the timeline.

    • Keb

      I’m not sure if there is a way :/ I do often note in the forums when I’ve updated. I’m working on putting in 304 and 305 right now. I do try to mark the episodes for each event (or evidence) in the timeline, so you can always look for those markers.

      305′s backstory is right after Baelfire’s birth (somewhat arbitrary–it could easily be a few years before then, but because Bae’s birth is really the starting point for so much of what has happened, I chose to put Killian’s backstory after it).

      304′s backstory is between 108 and 119 (though it’s not impossible that it happens between some of the events of 119, as in 219 and 112), so before Bae leaves the Enchanted Forest but after Rumple becomes the Dark One.

      I’m hoping to catch up with 306 and 307 sometime this week, but those two added a LOT of information that requires adjusting throughout the timeline…and I’m very behind on Wonderland as well. (Moving will do that to you.)

  • merryweather

    You need to put in the events from “Ariel.” According to the producers, Snow meets Ariel shortly after she meets Charming, but before she tries to see him again at King george’s castle. And of course you now have the events of “Think Lovely thoughts. I think that Rumple was about 8 years old.

    • Keb

      RumplesGirl and I thought we’d pin him around 7ish, though 8′s a reasonable estimate too. And I’ve adjusted events around Ariel to include the information from Adam’s twitter, so once I have a chance to timeline Ariel, I will be able to put it in the right place.

  • merryweather

    If you watch “The Miller’s Daughter” and then watch “Ariel,” you’ll probably notice that King Xavier’s kingdom is the same one as Prince Eric’s. It’s one and the same place just many years apart. I believe that Prince Eric is Prince Henry Sr.’s nephew. Watch the episodes and see if you agree. If you do, you can include it in your timeline.

  • Keb

    I’ve been working on adding events slowly. Had to move things around to accommodate Ariel’s timeline clue from Adam’s twitter, but that’s done, so we’re ready to add Ariel when I get time to do it. And interesting thought on Eric/Henry Sr. Wonder if that IS true…

  • Keb

    Timeline should be updated now through the events of Ariel.

  • Keb

    Timeline is now updated through the events of 308–Think Lovely Thoughts.

  • Janantha

    You’ve put the flashbacks of 107 The Heart is a Lonely Hunter in 8 B.C., and the flashbacks of 115 Red-Handed in 4 B.C. If you watch those scenes again, you’ll notice that Snow White is wearing the same outfit in both, just adjusted a little for the snowy weather. I don’t see her wearing the same clothes for four years, do you?

    Also, you have the flashbacks of 116 Heart of Darkness in July, whilst 115 Red-Handed is in February. But both flashbacks have snow. Assuming that the change of seasons in the Enchanted Forest mirrors that of Earth, that makes no sense unless they somehow jumped from one hemisphere to another.

    Lastly, Lana just tweeted that Regina’s birthday is February 1.

    https://twitter.com/LanaParrilla/status/412435053424029696

    Otherwise, great timeline!

    • Keb

      Great observations–I’ll see what I can do with them! I realize that the time from Snow leaving home and later events is absurdly stretched right now, but there’s conflicted evidence regarding her ages at various points. I’ll look into streamlining this, however. Thanks!

  • Lazarry

    will you add Once Upon a Time in Wonderland into the Timeline?

    • Keb

      Wonderland is slated to be timelined separately at present. It’s on the back burner but in progress.

  • Jesus Rodriguez

    i DIDN’T UNDERSTAND THE PART ABOUT ROLAND’S BIRTH IS REALLY CONFUSING.

    • Keb

      I’m not sure what you are confused about. Roland was 4 years old in 303 (Robin Hood said so), but time was frozen in the Enchanted Forest during the 28 years of the curse. So he’s 4+28 years old.

      I’m happy to clarify anything else in that entry if need be.

      • Jesus Rodriguez

        Thanks

  • http://www.yourtechnetwork.com/ Dennis Freitas

    Cool Idea with the TimeLine! My daughter just stopped me from reading this because we are only half way thru season 2. Cant wait to catch up. Again thanks for the timeline this had to be a lot of work!! Good Job Noodle.MX

  • Pingback: Donna Kauffman » Sunday Night Dish! Once Upon a Time, Downton Abbey, and Good Wife….here we go!

  • Sydnie

    Love this so much! Great reference. (You should call it Once Upon aTimeline)

  • brucegil

    KEB and Daniel. Just wondering when will we see episodes 309-311 in the outline. I am sure you are busy but it’s been a while since you added 308 details. This has been a great help in sorting out all the story lines. Keep up the good work.

    • Keb

      They’re up now! Don’t worry, I have no intention of stopping atm.

      • brucegil

        Thanks. I will check it. Looks like new episodes will be a little confusing.
        Sent from AOL Mobile Mail

  • Chelsea

    Is here any chance you could add a feature that lets us select a character from a list and find the dates specifically associated with them, as its very painstaking to have to sift through the centuries of events on here. =(

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      That’s a good idea, but our software will only allow six categorizations. That’s not enough to implement a great idea like this.

    • Keb

      I have a slightly more detailed timeline spreadsheet I’ve been working on that would allow one to read through a particular character’s story more or less…but there are at least 120 characters in Once without counting Wonderland so such tagging is painstaking work. It’s taken a back seat to getting the main timeline done anyway.

  • BadAndy

    Is there anything in this timeline about the Frankenstein story line? There isn’t anyway that it fits into the time space of the Enchanted Forest with that advanced technology and how that crosses in. Even pirates would have been a pretty major leap in technology in the Enchanted Forest with firearms and ships that advanced. Can anyone explain that?

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      It’s possible that Hook came from the same Fictional London as Alice.

      The “Land Without Color” is a separate, parallel world.

  • Keb

    The timeline is complete through 311 now. I’ve adjusted Rumple’s age to 200 to account for several factors (like Big Ben). And yes, the Land Without Color is a separate world but I’ve been including any events from Once Upon a Time in this timeline.

  • Melanie Zammit

    is there a way to show only the last added entries? I mean, I for example you added events from flashbacks its very hard to know where the entries had been added and end up scrolling from the beginning

    • http://DanielJLewis.net/about Daniel J. Lewis

      We’ll have to work that into the process.