- This topic has 101 replies, 28 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
OK so if Neil is Bae, then the whole hook and emma relationship would be terrible. Emma would be dating her baby daddys step father(presuming melah and hook were ever married) This sounds more like west virginia than a family show. Stop shipping them!!! lol
[adrotate group="5"]Hook and Milha were not married. They were only romantically involved with each other. There’s no relation between Neal and Hook. Niether through blood or marriage. It’s still ok to ship them.
If Hook and Emma did get together it wouldn’t last. Henry is the most important person in Emma’s life and Hook isn’t the most kid friendly of people. Hook’s not going to tolerate Henry for long and Henry wouldn’t want Emma with Hook because Hook is a “villain”.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixNo, it would still be extremely creepy to have Emma be romantically involved with her baby daddy’s, mother’s former lover.
@Gypsy wrote:
No, it would still be extremely creepy to have Emma be romantically involved with her baby daddy’s, mother’s former lover.
Totally agree.
Hahahah!! All humour put aisde..did you really have to make a new topic just for this?
I get it, you don’t like the ship, but please at least come up with a decent argument. 😆I think it’s a valid point.
To some ppl, not only is it extremely creepy, it’s weird and gross.
And what difference does it make – one more ‘Hook’ topic….there are sooo many already 😉I love the Captain Swan ship, and I know some people don’t but I’m still trying to understand why some people just really hate it/him so much! Neal’s not my favorite, but I don’t hate him! If Swantheif does happen, then there are other women in Storybrooke for Captain Hook!
I just don’t see any redeeming qualities in Hook. Yes, he’s easy on the eyes and charming but he doesn’t have any remorse for any of his wrong doings. That is what sets him apart from Gold/Rumple. He at least regrets letting Bae go and has been trying to rectify that situation. We’ve seen that Rumple started as a good man…flawed but essentially good….redemption is possible. We haven’t been shown anything (yet, I know we could see it and I could change my mind later) that shows that Hook can be redeemed. Plus, he would be a horrible step dad.
@Gypsy wrote:
No, it would still be extremely creepy to have Emma be romantically involved with her baby daddy’s, mother’s former lover.
When phrased like this… it sounds as if you would find it on those daytime television shows (Jerry Springer or similar).
It definitely shows how the six degrees of separation can create for some awkward connections.
Personally I like the idea of CaptainSwan only in so much they make an interesting pair however I do not think they would be able to go long-term (Hook and his deal with children and Emma’s life being Henry as someone else mentioned). They can at least some fun times though…
The topic ‘Eww CaptainSwan shippers’ is closed to new replies.