It is just another sword then? It isn’t special in some way. That is sort of sad. Then why did Rumpel give her her father’s sword specifically. Why keep it? Though i guess these objects could have just shown up in his shop when the curse happened and he didn’t actually collect them.
In reference to the sword….how did Rumple ever get possession of it. In the pilot both Charming and Snow picked it up. After it was thrown at the Queen it hit the wall in her castle. The only time Rumple touched it was when he blocked a blow and that was before he saves Snow.