[adrotate group="5"]
ONCE - Once Upon a Time podcast
Reviews, theories, and talk about ABC's Once Upon a Time TV show
Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › General discussion and theories › 2007?? What is the basis of this and is it still true? › Re: 2007?? What is the basis of this and is it still true?
Yeah, i agree that Emma’s birthday is the day that she arrived in the real world in real world terms. That only makes sense. I do not agree that Emma and Henry have the same birthday because Emma would know that and Emma would so say something. It makes no sense to me at all that they could gloss over that and pretend that Emma would not say something to Henry about it being his birthday.
Also in True North, Emma said she was in the system for 16 years to Mary and then when she was talking to Henry she said she was pretty young, just got out of the system when she met Henry’s father and got pregnant. So to me that means Emma was 16 when she got pregnant and had Henry at 17. It just makes no logical sense to me that Emma would know that it was Henry’s birthday and not say anything to him. It makes much more sense to me that Emma would lie about the age she was when she had Henry to Ashley who she just met.