If I were Colin and I saw heated passionate debates about my character I would know I was doing a good job. That’s the whole point of his character….he’s the bad boy people love to hate or want to save.
That being said, it’s easy to find lots of love for Hook everywhere. He’s kinda taking over most boards and forums with his fangirls. This is all a two way street. If you see negative threads about him…ignore them. When I see positive boards about him, I ignore them. There will always be people who disagree with you and if it’s ruining the experience for you then avoid it. It’s just a tv show….not the end of the world.