Reply To: Emma + Baelfire = Swanfire

I just want it to be March already. Just wanna know what happens now. :-/

You and everyone else in the Onciverse! On a positive note, we have Christmas just around the corner for those of you who celebrate and then the New Year!

My super shippy prediction: Hook’s magic potion fails. It’s seeing the dreamcatcher that does the trick. It’s a last resort by Hook to get Emma to remember. Neal told Hook to take her to his place.

Naturally, I’m in favor of this prediction, but aren’t both a talisman and the Blue Fairy’s blue elixir necessary to return a person’s true identity? It wasn’t enough for Belle just to hold her chipped cup; she also had to drink Blue’s potion from it for Lacey to vanish and Belle to emerge. So, I’m thinking Emma needs Blue’s potion AND the dreamcatcher/talisman to wake up, because frankly, Hook won’t be able to get her to fall in love with him in time for TLK to work like it did for Snow and Charming in 1×16. And frankly, I doubt all of the time in the world would be enough for Emma really to fall for Hook’s attentions. Hook said it himself. He’s Emma’s “good friend” who is her to help her remember. Yet, it “was a long shot” that TLK would work.