Reply To: Emma + Baelfire = Swanfire

Back to 3×14, I have to wonder at the people who still think Hook is Mr. Right for Emma Swan. Here’s a post I read which describes it so well:

But as to going with Captain Swan… Here is the thing.

One of the things CSers have been adamant about is that Hook has always believed Emma’s “lie detector thing” whereas Neal hasn’t.

Turns out Emma detected Hook was lying tonight but Hook was rather blasé about it.

What gives? I would have thought Killy the Hero would never hide anything from his True Love?

Sorry, Anon, but I still don’t buy it. And I seriously doubt the show is going down the road you suggested. [x]