I’m not convinced Rumple broke more than one deal. The deal for the bean was to let Milah and Killian go – actually thinking about it, did Rumple agree to those terms? I have a sneaky suspicion he didn’t. He said he wanted to see the bean first, they showed him, Milah asked if they had a deal and Rumple went on a tangent about Milah leaving Bae. So I guess in Rumple’s mind there probably wasn’t technically a deal to break. It’s all a bit eye-for-eye with Rumple and Hook, trying to one-up each other. Hook went too far with using his knowledge of the dagger to his advantage. Yes it worked the first time in regards to the finding who the magic belonged too. That is one deal, Hook’s silence for Rumple’s help. Using the threat of calling out Rumple to Belle wasn’t going to work again, and Hook should have known that. When he asked for his hand I thought he had something different to offer, but no he was silly enough to use the same information. I love Hook but he wasn’t very bright, but in words of Buffy ‘Love makes you do the wacky.’ However he didn’t have anything else to bargain with and I would guess in Hook’s mind Rumple was never going to hand over the hand if he just asked for it.
Yeah, I guess you are right- Rumple pretty much twists things to suit himself no matter what the situation, so I guess at the end of the day it comes down to what Rumple/DO thinks is true.
I do agree it was a long shot gamble that Killian shouldnt have pushed, but he as you also say, he didnt have anything else, nor would Rumple simply ‘hand’ over his hand (that’s bad I know, but I’m feeling goofy so there it is lol 😉 )- I mean he’s been hunting the crocodile for 300 odd years, he should have known it wouldnt end well for him- but yeah, agreed ‘Love makes you do some weird & silly things sometimes’ & also plot 😉
I wont complain to much about him making that deal though- I LOVED Killian with 2 hands- I honestly didnt miss the hook at all, Colin play’s Hook/Killian so well, that he screams pirate even in his new getup 🙂 *trails off into thoughts of CS hand holding…* <3