- This topic has 35 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 9 years, 7 months ago by .
-
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
The topic ‘Rumple's Heart’ is closed to new replies.
ONCE - Once Upon a Time podcast
Reviews, theories, and talk about ABC's Once Upon a Time TV show
Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › Season Four › 4×17 “Heart of Gold” › Rumple's Heart
Magic has made Rumple’s blood thick and goopy; only with the elixer can he be healed. But how long wlll the potion last? And how about the other villains–Regina and Hook–do they have the same condition?
I think we’ve seen with Hook’s heart, it’s pretty healthy — bright red and all. Regina’s we haven’t seen recently, so I don’t know what it’s like. But who knows? Maybe since Regina can also use true love magic, an automatic effect could be that it reversed the darkness in her heart?
I think we’ve seen with Hook’s heart, it’s pretty healthy — bright red and all. Regina’s we haven’t seen recently, so I don’t know what it’s like.
That’s true, though Hook’s heart has black on it 411. But, keep this in mind, Regina pulled out Zelena’s heart in 403 (thinking it was Marian’s) and that heart was bright red. And we know Zelena has got to have some darkness, right? So…who really knows?
Why, oh why do I get the feeling that this is only a Dark One condition?
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
I think with Rumple, it could come down to two things 1) It’s a side effect of being the Dark One for so many years and/or 2) How long Rumple’s been alive and using magic. Now in regards to the 2nd possible key point, Regina has only been around for a small fraction of the time as Rumple, and Hook is not a magic user.
Magic has made Rumple’s blood thick and goopy; only with the elixer can he be healed.
Hook would not have this condition if it’s specific to magic users — which he is not.
Magic has made Rumple’s blood thick and goopy; only with the elixer can he be healed.
Hook would not have this condition if it’s specific to magic users — which he is not.
Okay, I’ll buy that one. That one fits. Now explain Regina and Zelena?
I think with Rumple, it could come down to two things 1) It’s a side effect of being the Dark One for so many years and/or 2) How long Rumple’s been alive and using magic. Now in regards to the 2nd possible key point, Regina has only been around for a small fraction of the time as Rumple, and Hook is not a magic user.
Sure. Dark One Heart’s Condition. I guess I’ll take it.
However it would have been far more profound if Rumple had a literal broken heart and not “magic made my blood thick”
Uh, question. Why did Rumple need the potion in the past?
Magic has made Rumple’s blood thick and goopy; only with the elixer can he be healed.
Hook would not have this condition if it’s specific to magic users — which he is not.
Okay, I’ll buy that one. That one fits. Now explain Regina and Zelena?
Again, besides being sisters, Regina and Zelena both used magic.
However it would have been far more profound if Rumple had a literal broken heart and not “magic made my blood thick”
I was hoping for this too. Because it honestly would have made more sense, but I guess, this one makes sense too.
Again, besides being sisters, Regina and Zelena both used magic
And yet Zelena’s heart was bright red when Regina pulled it out of her in 403.
The topic ‘Rumple's Heart’ is closed to new replies.