Even though I wasn’t fond of them, I don’t think S1 Snow and David would have sacrificed a child the way that they did. And we know for a fact that S1 Emma would be so against ever giving Killykins the time of day….I think one of the last episodes that I truly enjoyed Emma was Second Star To The Right/Straight On Till Morning!
Emma hasn’t really been Emma in a looooong time. I miss the real Emma! And yeah, I totally agree that Snow and Charming from S1 never would’ve done to Lily what was revealed in S4. The writers are committing character assassination of the Charmings and everything that makes them likeable: their goodness and family love! Good thing Neal died before they could totally ruin him. They tired (e.g. Hook called Neal a “villain” and then Neal died in a stupid ooc way), but at least Neal got a (somewhat) honorable barrial, so to speak, being called a hero by Emma and Henry. If Neal had lived, Baevil might’ve happened (which might’ve been entertaining in a car-wreck sorta way, but would’ve made me really sad on the inside). At least I can comfort myself knowing MRJ is away from all this crap.
And Adam and Eddy are trying to show us Emma becoming dark when everything she has done was completely human! Cruella threatened her son, the jack(beep) last episode insulted one of her only friends, and Lily all but threatened the Charmings to Emma’s face.
So true! So far, all Emma has done is protect her loved ones, but we’re supposed to believe it’s her “inner darkness”? Okay then.
It wasn’t turning dark, she was acting in defense. If they really want us to believe Emma was going dark, have her kill a total innocent in a fit of rage, show her snapping at people for no good reason, let her have a complete change in demeanor….darker clothes, wilder hair, turn Emma from Sandra Dee to “You’re The One That I Want” Sandy!
Yeah. So far, Emma just comes across as Sandra Dee on her date with Killy Willy Poo. But I’m guessing based on spoilers, we’re going to see a totally dark Emma in the finale.
"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy