Saw this online, the girl uses canon show script to talk about SF, i post the link here bc has language, also all her posts are great but the last one is amazing, also she actually shows that in show, they actually say that SF meet btw 24th october ad 31st december 2001, wonder why Keb never realised this, on the 1st time August and neal meet, August clearly say that while she was the the sistem, but not that she left and there is no indications in show that she run from the sistem, means that SF meet after she was 18 years old, meaning that henry should have 9 in the pilot and if he was born in august would be in 2012 and no way he could have 11 in 2014. The link HERE
an excerp of the post:
Another fact to consider when thinking about Neal/Bae and the “bold” decision to kill him off is WHY?
.
We know why. Adam and Eddy told us. Over and over and over again.
.
Adam and Eddy WANTED TO KILL PRINCE CHARMING. ABC smartly told them “no!”.
.
They couldn’t kill David, so the two idiots INVENTED a Prince Charming they owned (Bae) AND KILLED HIM.
.
Don’t see the parallels?
.
Snow was a bandit. Emma was a theif.
.
David was pretending to be a wealthy prince. Neal was pretending to own a car.
.
Snow met David when she tried to rob him in “his” royal carriage. They fell in love. Emma met Neal when she tried to steal “his” car. THEY fell in love.
.
King George told Snow if she truly loved David, she would leave him forever even though it meant she’d be alone and miserable. Snow left. August told Neal if he truly loved Emma he would leave her forever even though it meant he’d be alone and miserable. Neal left.
.
Listen to Emma and Neal’s music in Tallahassee when she is smiling happily and kissing him by choice as he proposes. That music is Snow and Charming’s True Love theme played on an electric keyboard.
.
The pendant? Crossed realms per script via Belle because Emma and Neal were in TRUE LOVE (that’s right, NEAL and Emma sharing TRUE LOVE is cannon. Not fanfic, CANNON. It’s in the script. It happened.)
.
Emma and Neal were ABSOLUTELY endgame until the the two idiots realized “hey! We own Neal! We CAN kill Prince Charming! Yay!!!!!!” And the two idiots happily did.
.
THAT is why they killed Neal.
.
It wasn’t a bold choice. It was a bad idea that had been vetoed years earlier by people much smarter than they were.
.
Ever listen to the two idiots give an interview? They stupidly think “the audience knows where this is going” is a sign of FAILURE instead of SUCCESS, and they SOOOOO wanted to kill Prince Charming for the 10 years they spent planning the 1st season.
.
In the five minutes they spent planning all further seasons, they couldn’t think of anything to do. (Let’s apply logic: Saying they wanted to get the rights to Neverland and if they did they wanted Captain Hook to have a crush on Emma DOES NOT MEAN THAT THERE WAS ANY INTENT FOR HER TO RECIPROCATE THOSE FEELINGS). But the two idiots Wished on the Star power of Colin’s pretty face and made their idiotic disgusting rape culture show-killing dream come true: THEY KILLED THE PRINCE CHARMING ABC DIDN’T OWN: BAELFIRE.
.
EMMA AND BAE WERE ENDGAME FROM DAY ONE.
.
Rumpel wanted to find his son Bae. Snow and David wanted to find their daughter Emma
.
Emma (the child of true love and light magic) was destined to meet and FALL IN TRUE LOVE with Baelfire, AKA Neal Cassidy (the child of a loveless marriage and dark magic).
.
The Scripts, the show’s PREMISE, JMo’s performances with MR-J, CO’D statement that Hook was a sociopath, and MR-J shock at being fired ALL support this.
.
It was perfect, elegant, and beautiful.
.
Too bad the idiots wanted to kill Prince Charming more then they wanted to write a good TV Show. THAT is why they killed Baelfire, aka Neal Cassidy, the Cannon True Love of Emma Swan.
All of this. Although, I personally like to have them meet in February, just to give them a year before August ruins things. I also like to make Henry nine in the pilot (the same pilot that claimed that Regina poisoned the apple because Snow was prettier than her, by the way — Early Installment Weirdness!) and add an unmentioned year-long time skip while Graham is still alive, which also accounts for Ashley drinking in “Skin Deep.”