Oh I disagree a bit. He’s the most polarizing, to be sure, but that stems from his overwhelming popularity back in his introduction and how people viewed him with Emma. I think in more recent years the dislike has become more vocal because more fandoms (ie: not just SQ and SF) have joined in but those those who loved Hook only love him more now and they are still a large portion of the fanbase.
You’re both right. He’s a base-breaker. Those who like him, LOVE him. Those who dislike him, HATE him. And he has only become more divisive over the years.
Pretty much that.
Also, Sean’s tweet is….interesting.
[adrotate group="5"]
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"