But not telling somebody something is not lying. Hook is by no means innocent but when it comes to the past year he doesn’t have to divulge everything. No one’s going to want to be like ‘oh yeah I was so upset I lost you I turned into a scumbag again’ especially when according to everyone, including Emma, Hook’s feelings for her are stronger than hers are for him. And he didn’t lie at the mirror. He said he didn’t find Eric. Emma downplayed it as modesty and then the conversation got broken up.
Is is not lie by omission of certain key facts? Shouldn’t Emma have all facts at her disposal?
What they are doing to Henry though, as a collective is going to have some major ramifications. Henry isn’t a child anymore. He’s growing up. He sees through the charade and is playing along for Emma’s sake. That is not good.
On this we agree