Yes, I find her creepy/scary. In all the cast interviews they talked about what was scary about the WW is that you don’t know what it is exactly that she is after – every episode she is after someone else and it isn’t quite clear what she is doing. I would agree and I think that is what makes her scary. She seems to know a lot – at least she knows just what to threaten people with/how to freak them out. But she is also just plain creepy and weird and one fry short of a Happy Meal. Like it didn’t make sense to me why she freaked out so bad when she found out that she was “adopted” or had a sister, and her obsession with Rumple was bizarre in a very disturbing way (“I made you a meat pie!”).
Plus Rebecca does this overacting thing that totally works for the character. I mean that in a good way.
It is very strange to be this far into a character’s arc and still have no idea what it is that she is doing! LOL