Reply To: Emma + Baelfire = Swanfire

[TheWatcher]

guess I’m an anomaly of an SF shipper…I love the character of Hook and I see a lot of chemistry in CS

See now, before S3 began I was one of the biggest Hookers around. Now? not so much. My problem with him isn’t because of a ship, ny problem with him is just what his character has become since falling for Emma. I started to not like him as much very early on in S3A and it continually got worse for me. i dont deny Hook and Emma have some kind of chemistry. I guess. But I preferred the chemistry between Emma and Jefferson more than that of Hook/Emma. Its not about their chemistry though, its about the characters. Looking at Hooks actions and motivations and just who he is in general, i simply CANNOT bring myself to want Emma to be with him. At all. If i had my way, Hook would have died a hero at the end of the neverland arc helping Rump to defeat Pan, burying the hatchet between them for good, and cementing himself as an OUAT hero. But now, he’s just there. Doing…not much. Like others have said, he really has no purpose in the show and I can’t imagine what else they have in store for him other than goo-goo eyes for Emma. Hook really has nothing more to do.

I think Hook with someone else would have been incredibly entertaining to watch

HookedQueen is where id like to have seen the show gone. Its not a huge stretch of my imagination to see those two together.

But by setting the ship up in opposition to SF, and then concluding SF they way they did, CS is a little painful to watch now

Yep. Neal didn’t have to die for CS to happen…. Well. Okay, maybe he did cause there is no way Emma would really have chosen hook over, ya know, a good man >> but still.