Reply To: Anna and Charming Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › Season Four › 4×02 “White Out” › Anna and Charming › Reply To: Anna and Charming October 6, 2014 at 6:50 pm #284580 RumplesGirlKeymaster True but the shepherd seem to imply that Ruth and Charming’s father had a reasonably happy marriage until his death. I have to agree. Charming’s story about his father in 402 didn’t quite seem on par with what we were led to believe in The Shepherd. [adrotate group="5"] "He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"