Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › Character discussion › Emma + Baelfire = Swanfire › Reply To: Emma + Baelfire = Swanfire
Seriously! This will be a rant. Colin said:
“I think what it is, is the connection that Hook and Emma have. Nobody’s really had the same thing because both have experienced similar things in their past and sort of been abandoned as kids,” he says. “Both of them are thieves. Emma’s done the wrong thing at the wrong time as well for whatever reasons she’s felt were necessary. They kind of see that in each other.”
Utter bull crap! Nobody else ever experienced the same thing as Emma? YES, SOMEONE ELSE FREAKING DID! HIS NAME WAS NEAL CASSIDY!
Colin just more accurately described Neal and Emma than he did Hook and Emma. Baelfire = Lost Boy, Emma = Lost Girl. Both grew up as orphans. Emma stole Neal’s already stolen car. They had that whole Bonnie-and-Clyde-act in Tallahassee.
How unoriginal is CS if Colin has to grasp at straws to try and explain why Emma and Hook “share a connection” ? Just no. Don’t try and take the SF story and pin it ontp CS to try and sell it. Utter baloney!
Utter nonsense for Hook to try and make it out like Emma was some sort of pirate in a past life. NO SHE FREAKING WASN’T! Thief =/= Pirate. Emma was a petty thief, just like Neal, but only because they had to survive and never harmed anyone else in the process. Hook, by contrast, was more than just stealing bread to survive: he was a pirate who killed, robbed, committed adultery, and preyed upon the weak and vulnerable just because he could.
How utterly false to claim only Hook and Emma understood each other. NO! Hook was raised by his older brother, and then turned rogue. He claimed it was to fight a tyrannical king, but no king forced Hook to rob, plunder and prey upon the weak and defenseless like poor crippled Rumple, before the was the dark one.
Emma and Neal weren’t raised by older siblings. They weren’t handed a career in any darn royal navy. No, they had nothing but each other.
This makes no sense at all, that even people that dont ship SF, when reading this, said that he described Neal and not Hook, in fact i think there is a interview in S2 i think where JMO used the same words to describe SF.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".