I…i like this theory… However, wouldn’t that mean that Zelena raped Rump. In order for lily to be that age, that would mean she was conceived while rump was under zelena’s control. It couldn’t have been around the time they met because she would have to be older than Emma. Also, this theory could be plausible because itd play into the whole “I am the one you love the most” thing that rump said. I thought it was odd.
Ah! I thought about this:
She got pregnant just before she used the silver slippers to get back to Oz. When she found out she was pregnant she freaked out and took a potion to pause the pregnancy (stopping any symptoms and the fetus from growing), but when she was transported back in time to our world the potion’s effects were negated and the pregnancy started to continue on as normal.
"so there’s this new show….."
"there’s lesbians in it"