Season 6 might be the last season of the show. Lost only ran for 6 seasons plus A&E have other shows they probably want to focus on like the Friday the 13th tv show.
I’d be quite annoyed if they killed off Robin and left him dead. Granted he’s not the most dynamic of characters but he has two young children, to permanently kill him after the “heroes” spending the half season rescuing Hook, who’s a lot less deserving, from death is an absolute kick in the teeth. It firmly puts Hook in “creator’s pet” territory. Considering he’s such a divisive character as it is, to do that wold only make him more unlikeable.
They can’t even take the old Buffy route of magic death vs mortal death aka Buffy could be brought back because she was killed by magic and thus it was an “unnatural” death whereas Tara couldn’t because she was shot and there fore it was a “natural” death.
Neal was killed by magic and wasn’t brought back whereas Hook was stabbed through the chest and was brought back. Whichever route they went, Neal’s and Hook’s manner of death would contradict it.
I hope they don’t try and make Regina go all Dark Willow.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of Felix