I never said you were jumping to conclusions or getting your hopes up, nick. I think your reasoning is sound. There is certainly a possibility that the scenes with Robin and Emma in front of the town hall happen after the new york scenes because of what Amy said about being in 523, I don’t know anything about what this katman person has said about the episodes and didn’t use any of that as evidence. All of the evidence i suggested was about who was or wasn’t in certain scenes. That is solid evidence from pictures of the filming.
I am not going to blame you if i am wrong or even care all that much. I don’t really care whether or not Robin dies because i find him to be a completely unimportant character. The only characters i don’t want to die right now are Emma, Regina, or Snow and that seems pretty unlikely.