*sigh*
Really? We’re doing this again? I’m not saying this as a way to shut down conversation but…why? After–what–fiveish years of constant fighting and arguing does anyone really think they have the necessary linchpin to sway someone to the other side?
People like Hook for valid reasons. People do not like Hook for valid reasons. And still others simply shrug and care deeply neither way.
The only thing this is proving is that Hook is still a divisive character because–oh,shocking–texts are subjective and we read them differently based on our own morals, experiences and ideas about right/wrong, good/bad. Everyone’s argument is boiling down to “if you can’t see X then I don’t know what to tell you…”
But by all means….debate away. Even though it’s 100% futile.
(But for the love of heaven, blacken out your spoilers! Even allusions to future events are spoilers. As they have been for 6, years.)