Reply To: Why is Hook such a divisive character within the fandom?

[TheWatcher]

(Wow, so I typed up a reply and it didn’t post -____- RG If u see double post, feel free to delete one)

Anyway:

– I don’t thin Hook is Black Fairy’s son all because it makes the already crazy fmily tree even crazier. Plus I don’t see what gain there would be. Its not like Hook and Rump are going to be buddy, buddy.

– @Michael, Hook very well could die or split from Emma. Unless you know what the writers have planned. Afterall, other characters who had relevance in the story and were built up died with absolutely no payoff at all.

– Michael, outside of Hook living and being with Emma, I’m asking what more do you want from his character? Or is that just enough for you?

– Um, Regina would be leaving behind something. She has a son, Henry. And she has Roland. And she has her entire family. She has more to lose than Rumpel does. Her dying is incredibly unlikely, but Rumpel dying is probably going to happen. I want it to at least.

– I want Hook to have a story outside of emma, and here is the thing, this season has perfectly set it up. HIS BROTHER IS IN STORYBROOKE! Let the guy go on some kind of seafaring adventure or something!!!!! Let them bond. Let them fight. There is so much potential that  could be created with that.