Reply To: Hook's Crime

[Michael]

I don’t understand why does it matter that he was David’s father? If it was just random nobody, would it be ok? Would he feel bad about it?

Quote

Of course he would, as we saw last season Killian killed people and he never forgets them. He uses things like the rings as a reminder of his past and to not go back to it. It was in Birth.

So of course he recognized the person on site. But then again his kill count is probably nowhere close to Regina or Rumple’s level.