Not sure I actually liked the CS proposal. I don’t think I enjoy that Emma found the ring beforehand. To me, it ruined the proposal and the surprise. They needed to do it that way so that Hook could keep his secret a little longer without the audience being mad at him for doing it. PLOT PLOT PLOT got in the way of a better CS proposal. And not to mention Hook was drunk! He had like 5 shots at Granny’s.
Yeah … but they live together… and those things happen… putting away laundry into the drawers / sea chest … OH MY A RING! IT is hard to keep secrets from people you live with.
Same with the DIRTY PIRATE KILLS GRAND PA … the secret will be outed.