I’ve argued this before in the dark Hook nonesense. Loosing your memory should not take away your dark intentions. Baelfire never had those murderous tendencies, it would have surfaced again at one point, but we never saw that.
It doesn’t help that the show is overflown with inconsistencies about how the dagger works (remember when Emma heard voices and it never came up again?).
[adrotate group="5"]
"All your questions are pointless"