I think that perhaps opening a new thread “was Baelfire OOC?” would have been more welcomed. Think about if there had been a thread “positive things about OUAT” and I would have posted negative things, it would not have been welcomed.
Yup, fair point. But then the thread shouldn’t be called Emma + Bealfire = Swanfire. It should be called, “Only post positive things about Neal, negative things about Hook, and how the show hasn’t written Neal right since they killed him off.” Then I would stay away from any counter opinions. But as far as I know, this thread is generally about Neal/Baelfire and Emma. At least that is what the thread title suggests. So me posting why I felt he was not necessarily OOC should not be unwelcome. And for the most part, it wasn’t. Again, I like a good debate where people can back up things they say etc. It was Rainbow that got under my skin.