Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › General discussion and theories › The Captain Swan thread! › Reply To: The Captain Swan thread!
She states in her vows that what she experienced with Hook is TRUE LOVE! Don’t try to make it anything other than what it is.
She stated that she loved Neal. Don’t try to make it make it anything other than what it is. The show stated their love was also TRUE LOVE! Don’t try to make it anything other than what it is.
Those were “magical forces” even if YOU don’t take it to be that.
Yes, they were magical forces but they both were not indicative of True Love between Hook and Emma. The underworld test would have worked regardless of Hook because Emma has a heart full of love. Because she is light magic and true love incarnate, and the savior. Her heart was already shown to be a powerful force of love in SEASON 2. The only confirmation of love I see is the door. But still, Hook and Emma never received TLK. Which is still extremely odd.
it is completely clear within the narrative that Emma and Killian ARE true love. And no amount of arguing or headcanons you say will be able to say otherwise.
Sure. Just like Emma and Neal.
She did love Neal yes. But it wasn’t true love. He was her first love and perhaps it was true love on his side but it was not on hers. She did not experience true love until Killian, GET. OVER. IT.
Again what Belle of all people says is irrelevant especially back then because she had no idea how Emma feels.
Umm no they were indicative of true love. As they specifically stated IN DIALOGUE about the meaning of both magical items connecting to true love between two people. Get away from those headcanons dear, focus on the canon. Emma and Killian are true love. You sound just like SQ shippers now and that’s not a good thing, LOL.
I don’t care if they didn’t get a TLK because they didn’t need one because the show has explicitly stated it’s true love. Just cause delusional people still refuse to see it doesn’t mean it isn’t there. It’s stated in canon, it is canon. They’re a unique pairing, a freaking couple like Zades got true loves kiss. Sometimes it’s not a good thing to get the true love kiss. They get things that other couples do not get, that are unique.
Wile Emma and Neal never got any explicit confirmation of true love. No magical item, nothing except the dialogue from Belle about the stupid ring which BTW may indicate true love from Neal, but clearly not from Emma.