I was hoping I wouldn’t have to tell you.” Does Emma mean she didn’t want to tell Charming, full stop, but her conscious got the better of her? Or does Emma mean that she was hoping Hook would go and tell Charming?
I think she meant that she had to tell him instead of Hook
That doesn’t sound like it. It clearly seems to hint us that she was willing to lie. That would be like how She lied to Henry about his dad. Like Grandfather like Grandson.
I thought David’s reactions were legit and completely in character. He is not saying he will never forgive Hook but that he has every right to be angry especially since Emma was the one to tell him instead of Hook
Yeah he had the right to be angry at him for murdering his dad. And like his mother, Snowing’s parents, Henry’s dad, & Wish Henry’s grandparents, Robert deserves justice. Also like villains such as Regina, that is also a sign that Hook has not fully redeemed himself when continuing on lying and did not make up to what he just did to Robert.