"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
Alice’s father is made of wish power. Maybe that’s an important part of Gothel’s plan.
Thaaaaat makes a lot of sense, actually!
I don’t see what realm Nook is from or has been to would make a difference.
If it was any other realm, it wouldn’t matter at all. But since Nook was created by a wish (an impossible thing) I think @gaultheria might be on to something with the fact that Nook possibly passed on some sort of wish making ability.