Do you think it’s possible the H/G from this season may not originally be from EF2? As in, could they be H/G from S1 or their Wish Realm counterparts?
I’m going to say they aren’t the H/G from S1 because the blind witch is 100% different (we met her earlier this season, yes? The blind old witch in the candy sop). But they could be from the Wish Realm instead of EF 2 EXCEPT that, once again, we run into the whole “wish realm didn’t exist until it was wished into existence in S6, which was a long long long time AFTER H/G from S1 had encountered Regina/the Blind Witch who liked butter and gravy” thing.
Unless they ran into both Blind Witches. By pure happenstance.