Hahaha maybe. It is pretty easy to over think with this show when you learn how complicated it can get. Similar over-thinking happened a lot with LOST. 😛
Fans have a very active imagination. Honestly, the fans come up with a lot of theories that could have turned out better than what we actually got. I recall Eddy and Adam even responding with “Wow! Why didn’t we think of that?” when talking about fan theories they’ve heard of.