@Faux Pax wrote:
God i hope not. There have been soooo many SwanFire hints…
Yes, I don’t think that the dad can be anyone but Mysterious Man aka Baelfire. I even looked up the other actors’ pictures that are listed, and none of them look like there’s any chance that they could be the father. Of course, all the fire hints related to Henry’s dad like him being a fireman and his arrow being on fire in the People magazine pictures, and the parallels between the openings of season 1 and season 2 between Emma and Mysterious Man.
Also, if Hook was Henry’s dad, if he could just travel between worlds, then it would be simple for him to leave whatever is left of the Magical Worlds and all the harsh conditions like the ogres coming back and whatnot since he doesn’t seem like the noble type that sticks around to help others but is more of a guy that is about having a good time at least based on the pictures from The Crocodile where it appears he laughs at Rumple in front of young Bae.