I think the writers have thrown to much out there pointing as August to be Pinocchio for him to BE Pinocchio. I think the want us to believe that he is Pinocchio when in fact they will suprise us with who he really is. They have thrown out both Baelfire and Pinoccio as options for who August is which makes me think he isn’t either of them. Again I can’t get over his liscense plate being from Kansas…and the year 1984 on it is when the curse was innacted…that was 28 years ago, have you noticed that everyone in town drives cars from that time frame. EQ thought he looked familiar…he knows about the book. I think August may have been in SB this whole time just hidding out and waiting just like Jefferson. Just because no one has ever seen him doesn’t mean he wasn’t there. And what about the room that he used to add pages to the book. The writers said he was adding his own story. How would he have access to that room and materials if he was from out of town. I think his identity is going to be way out there like he is a Grimm, or the Wizard of Oz…something out there that the writters have barely clued us into. Personaly I think that Dr. Whale is Pinocchio…who was swallowed by a whale, hence the name. I don’t know…but we have a few weeks to speculate…