Faux Pas- I didn’t get that from TheGoldenKey’s theory, at all.
GoldenKey- The whole thing with Bae being Peter Pan could very likely work…if Bae went to Neverland when he used the magic bean from BF and then at some point Bae/ PP crossed over from Neverland to our world (as we know PP could do) maybe he couldn’t get back to Neverland…so he remained in our world and started to age normally and met Emma…..