There is a fine line between telling the story you want to tell and giving fans what they want. You can’t please everyone all of the time. For all the people calling for Hook to stay around and be redeemed, there are also people who don’t like Hook and want him gone. Sometimes it’s not a matter of whether a character is liked or not but how best they serve the story.
Would people prefer Hook to be around for a short while and actually be involved in plots or have him around for a long while with nothing really to do?
@magic bean wrote:
It’s just so obvious that Hook wil let go of his revenge, for Emma. But he doesn’t need to change, because he’s Emma’s match, all he has to do is let go of his revenge, which has blinded him for years.
I’m trying to say all of this without letting my Captain Swan feelings take over.
Why would Hook let go of his revenge that has been his main focus for centuries for a woman he’s only really known for a couple of days and who abandoned him at the top of the beanstalk?
Hook may flirt with Emma and he may be able to connect with her but it’s not enough to override his lust for revenge against Rumple.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of Felix