Personally, not liking Pinocchio’s fairy tale isn’t my reason for not liking the Pinocchio theory at all. I actually do like Pinocchio and I would love for him to be in the show. It’s just that I don’t want him to be August or the seven year old boy who found Emma or even grown up at all. I’d rather he and Geppetto be in Jefferson and Grace’s situation, separated from each other by the curse. But I do think there’s a lot of evidence pointing toward Pinocchio and August probably is him and the writers probably can reveal it in a way I will like, even though they haven’t won me over yet and I would still rather him be someone else.