@Phee wrote:
@charming wrote:
we cannot in our predictions or theories talk for the characters or suggest things to they are fact when it is based on speculation to start with.
Speculation that Kathryn may have stumbled over the threshold and as such could have remembered is based on the fact that her car was right where that threshold is. If all we can discuss about the show is hard facts we have, that takes half the fun out of the whole experience of the show IMO.
Yes, true and you do have a valid point. However, saying something is fact based on a spectulation of another spectulation while disregarding what is fact and putting word into characters’ mouths’ who have not said anything to the affect of what is suggested and on events that have not happened or even come close to ever possibly happeneing due to the mere fact that nothing was said for or against that theory is not good. It is no better than just making it up. Our theories have to be based on facts. Going so far off the reservation based guesses upon guesses is not fun. Some people can view this as or may say like Emma said in the Pilot, “Really!!”.