I’d say Belle for mayor, but I’d be fine with Granny. As for sheriff, my first choice is Grumpy. Like the others, he seemed to be head of Snow’s guards in the Enchanted Forest. I can see him stepping up to the plate.
I imagine we’ll see a return of King George. He’s still hiding out in Storybrooke. With the Charmings, Rumple and Regina gone, I can see this as a prime time for him to come back and try to take back power he lost in the Enchanted Forest. He probably has some that are still loyal to him. He’s great at whipping up the crowd into a frenzy as we saw with Ruby’s lynch mob. Without David or Snow there to lead them, I can see these people turning to George, who they are familiar with. Sometimes it’s better the devil you know…
Keeper of Rumplestiltskin's and Neal's spears and war paint and crystal ball.