This is the episode with the Seer right?
What if she’s just showing Rumple what could have been but isn’t because of his defection from the army during the War? We know that’s a really sore spot with Milah. So instead of coming home to a wife who loves him, he comes home to a woman who hates him and has had another man’s baby.
Wait wait wait!! So you mean that Rumple isn’t bae’s father?
It’s a long standing theory. It was hinted at in “A Desperate Soul”
[adrotate group="5"]
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"