I don’t think he is Bal.
He is clumsy (phone out the window) and I think that is somehow an important clue to his identity.
The age doesn’t really match up. He was 14(?) when he came to ‘our land’ and here Emma is 17 (11 years previous). How do we explain Bal aging about 10 years from his Fairytale exit to being just a few years older than Emma 11 years prior to Rumple’s prediction to curse broken.
I do like the theory that he is Peter Pan and the suggestions behind that
About the book, I still think Snow wrote it in those last few months of pregnancy