I think it’s pretty equal. Some fans feel that if one villain is redeemed, then other won’t be. Personally, I think they’ll both redeemed in the end. But in regards to who’s more evil, I really can’t say.
I agree. I always laugh whenever I see Regina and Rumpel fans arguing over who’s mor evil. I just wanna smack them upside the head and say THEY BOTH ARE! 😆 But judging from most sites, fans tend to lean slightly more on the “Regina is more evil” side. *Sigh* I don’t get it.
But like you said, they’ll probably both be redeeemd in the end. Rumpel by Baelfire and Belle, and Regina by Henry.