I would just like to point out, we are the land with-out magic. There couldn’t be anything magical about August’s box or the thing he showed Neal in it, because until Rumple brought Magic there was no magic.
I do like the ideal that the Blue Fairy set up everything she needed to remember and then help guide August to do as he was meant to. Yet as August said. our world had to many temptations. Maybe that is why she said that she had to leave so her and the other fairies had to make preparations to help a wayward August. I think the 20,000.00 was to much a temptation for August though..
So what ever was shown to Neil could not have been anything magical and a Tinkerbell in a box would be way magical. 😀