^Yes. The theory that Neal is also PP wasn’t just a random thought someone had. Gypsy and TheGoldenKey put a lot of it together, very similiar to how they figured out who Whale was.
Many people could say they were red herrings but there WERE SO MANY that I’m not quite willing to give up the ghost of Nealfire Pan.
Watch ABC give out too many clues concerning Peter Pan’s identity in a continuation of The Untold Stories Facebook game this summer/fall. That’s basically what gave away that Whale was Victor Frankenstein. 😆