Would it not be hilarious if the writers/producers of OUAT decided to wait till the end of season 2 to reveal his identity? I’m not so certain that the average viewer cares that much about whale and it would be an excellent way to send the fandom into… lightly veiled madness.
Gypsy – see, that is the problem with ideas, I don’t think I stole this theory from anyone (not consciously) but I doubt I came up with it by myself.
I think I saw a post a few days ago of, what I think was the original owner of the theory, dated august 23.