Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › Season Three › 3×12 “New York City Serenade” › 312 Promo › Reply To: 312 Promo
I just don’t think it’s the right size to be a photo. It looks like the ends of whatever it is fit inside her fists, so it’s only a couple inches wide at most, and it’s several inches long. Unless it’s a panoramic photo, the dimensions simply aren’t right for it to be a photo.
If she is in Neal’s apartment, and it is something from their past, it would have to be something we would recognise as well, otherwise it’s too random for them to include it. They didn’t have many things though, so the only thing I could think that it could be is if he’d cut a strip out of the map, the part that had Tallahassee on it. That idea might be a bit far fetched, but on the other hand, this is gonna be another ep named after a city, (and we’re also seeing the dream catcher from the same scene the map was in), so part of the map might actually be a fitting prop.
Neal and Tamara would not mean much to Emma, nor even young Neal and Emma,unless her memory erased him and how she got that car.
Far as we know, her memories were only changed from the birth of Henry and beyond. So she still remembers everything about her old life with Neal. If Hook’s trying to get her to believe him, then pointing her in the direction of something from her past that he couldn’t possibly know about would be a way to prove to her that he’s legit. The only people who know details about Emma’s old life with Neal, are Emma and Neal, because it’s not like they used to mingle and associate with other people who got to know them and their stories of their life together. So it’s not like Hook could plant these things to mess with her, he must actually know Neal.