Reply To: Hook's History With the Lost Ones, Peter Pan, and Neverland

[RumplesGirl]

Despite all my misgivings about Hook, I don’t want to believe that he lied to Bae about his father in order to learn of Rumple’s secret. To me, that was one of the few times I’ve seen “Killian” instead of Hook. I think he may have gone to Bae in order to learn about Rumple, but I think his intentions changed once Bae told Hook about what Rumple had done. Then pirate facade dropped and he was honest. But…I do admit that given the scene directly before that where Hook tells Smee that he can use Bae to learn about Rumple, I need to keep an open mind.