I’m liking these theories although I don’t like the idea of Neal being separated from his family again (cue Neal being the punching bag character again…seriously writers?!), I can see this being a decent story. I didn’t see this theory posted yet but what if when Neal goes back to NYC to get his things, he’s nabbed for stealing Tamara’s car (driving it back there would be a logical way for him to get around since he apparently doesn’t have a car of his own) and they also start questioning him about her disappearance which escalates things from there and requires the others to come help him out? We have no idea if that car is in both of their names or only in her name so without her being there to confirm it, they could easily nab him for stealing the car and then find out about Tamara being gone. Hmmm, lots to think about with this theory but it does have legs and it could be where they’re going with things. Why would they do this though? What does the potion have to do with anything? How does everyone leave SB? Why is Emma wearing those horrible plaid pants? Geesh, I have no clue aside from my ‘Neal Has to Be the Punching Bag Character’ comment which they seem to be stuck on. Poor guy. 🙁
#MoreBOOMLessGloom