Seriously though, imagine if they take Neal in for questioning and they’re all, “When was the last time you saw Tamara?” Not like he can answer honestly. If they wanna hook him up to a lie detector, he’s officially screwed. All he could say is, “I’m not answering anything without my lawyer,” which would then mean that he’d have to depend on Rumple to get him out of trouble, which would be an important stepping stone in their reconciliation.
I would love to see Snarky Lawyer Rumple save his son. It would be rather amazing.
I don’t know if it’s cracky, I actually think it makes a lot of sense if we put some pieces together. So things we KNOW:
1) Hook, Henry, and Emma are in NYC for sure
2) Reports of Snow, Nealfire, Belle and Rumple also being in NYC (Charming most likely is also there but just no sighting as of yet)
3) The only characters associated with NYC are Nealfire and Tamara
4) They were filming outside of a police station
5) Tamara has a grandmother and probably other “real” world connections who would notice that she hasn’t been seen for a few days. ALSO: let’s not forget that THO is really PP and his minions, meaning that when our gang disposes of PP, as we know they will, THO could potentially seek revenge by setting up the heroes to deal with real world problems
6) Emma drinks a potion given to her by Hook (where did he get it??)
Because we have photos of Emma and Henry together, I think we can discount the “Henry goes missing theory”
Because we have photos of Emma and Hook together, I think we can discount the “Hook goes missing theory”