I agree with much of what you said, truidia. We don’t use the catchphrase, “Sneaky Fairy is sneaky” around here for nothin’. 😉
4) Speaking of Pinocchio, August sure had a lot of information regarding Neal who he never met before. We know that August had some contact with the Mother Superior in Storybrooke. And she certainly knew who Bae was. Additionally she was the only one who would have known everyone’s story and therefore been in the position to write Henry’s book.
Adam tweeted RumplesGirl a few months back confirming that Blue didn’t have her memories during the cursed years. It crushed many of our theories that she was a “big bad”. I’d been convinced that she was the one who had orchestrated Henry’s adoption, and convinced that she’s the one who had told August all about Bae, but that can’t be the case if she didn’t have her memories during the time August was in SB. I think it will turn out that August found out about Nealfire from The Home Office…which is ultimately controlled by PP…who is Blue’s boss.
So I do agree with all of your points that suggest she’s been an agent working with a secret, nefarious motive to manipulate events all these years. (I also agree that she’s likely the one who wrote the book.)
I dunno that she’ll be playing a dual role as Tink though, (I’d expect her to be blonde and dressed in green…please God not the same style of costume as Blue’s ridiculous jellyfish dress), but I do think she knows Tink, and has been communicating events in FTL back to Tink in NL, so that Tink could keep PP up to date on proceedings.